Reading index / General education
Choose the detail a prototype needs
A prototype is a representation made to explore an idea. Its value depends on what it helps someone learn. A convincing appearance and a useful test are related only when appearance is part of the question.
Choose the question first
A paper sketch may help someone discuss a sequence of screens. A working mechanism may reveal whether parts move as intended. A material sample may help examine texture. These representations answer different questions; none is automatically the best starting point.
Fidelity describes how closely a prototype represents selected aspects of a possible final design. It can be high in one aspect and low in another. A realistic enclosure might contain no functioning electronics, while working software might have only a plain interface.
Make the omissions explicit
Hypothetical example: a cardboard handheld object could help explore whether controls are within reach. It would not establish battery life, structural durability or production cost. Recording those omissions keeps observations from being stretched into conclusions the model cannot support.
Preserve what was learned
Keep a short record of the prototype version, the question, the observations and the next unresolved issue. Separate what a participant did from an interpretation of why they did it. A comment and an observed action can be informative in different ways.
Refinement becomes worthwhile when more detail is needed to investigate the next uncertainty. A prototype can be useful even when it is discarded. Its contribution may be a clearer question, an exposed constraint or an option that no longer needs to be pursued.